Oscar-nominated actor Michael Keaton revisited his iconic roles as Batman and Beetlejuice during his guest-hosting stint on late night sketch show Saturday Night Live this weekend by delivering a few lines as the popular characters in his opening monologue, much to the studio audience’s delight.

The Birdman star also showed off his comedy skills in a creepy Easter segment, in which he donned a blond wig and proceeded to show off the contents of his Easter basket, including an “eggscellent” dyed egg, a rabbit soft toy he named Glenn, in honor of Glenn Close’s bunny-boiling character in Fatal Attraction, and unleavened bread for his Jewish friends, which he explained, “unlike Jesus, it doesn’t rise.”

The sketch may have put hole generations of viewers off Easter candy for a while!